Falling Faster

A recent paper by  Alexander Klotz of McGill University, Montreal, has stirred a bit of interest in the pop-science press.  The paper looks at the old question of the time taken to fall through a hole passing through the centre of the Earth, and back up to the surface at the opposite point on the Earth’s surface.  This calculation makes the usual assumptions of a perfect vacuum, and zero friction, but instead of the usual simplification of assuming the Earth to be of constant density, it allows for the actual estimated varying density along the length of the hole, and finds that the transit time would be reduced from 44 minutes to just over 38 minutes.

There is a good article on the paper at How long would it take you to fall through Earth?, and a rather more excitable one at How Long Would It Take To Fall Through The Center Of The Earth?

The latter article suggests that “Klotz went where no physicist has gone before”.  I suppose that is possible, but I know that at least one engineer has looked at the question before, I have on this very blog:

The hole through the middle of the Earth – revised transit time

I came up with a time of 38 minutes and 57 seconds, compared with 38 minutes and 11 seconds found by Klotz.

Another surprising finding was that if a constant acceleration of 9.81 m/s2 is assumed all the way to the centre, then -9.81 m/s2 all the way back up to the surface, the transit time is only reduced to 38 minutes.  The graph below shows what is happening; the effect of increasing density is that the acceleration does remain close to constant over much of the journey, and it is only in the final stages that the velocity assuming constant acceleration becomes significantly faster than the velocity based on the actual (estimated) density.


More links on the topic of holes through the middle of the Earth:

The hole through the middle of the Earth – moved to the Equator

The hole through the middle of the Earth – filled with air

Elegant solutions, Column buckling, and the hole through the middle of the Earth

This entry was posted in Excel, Maths, Newton and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Falling Faster

  1. excel1star says:

    Another source for Alexander Klotz’s paper http://arxiv.org/pdf/1308.1342v1.pdf

    Liked by 1 person

    • dougaj4 says:

      Thanks Alfred (have another star).

      I wanted to look at the numbers actually used in the paper, but not badly enough to pay $30-40 for it!


  2. Alex Klotz says:

    Hello, this is Alex Klotz. I’m glad to see other people are interested in this problem. Another person who studies this time of thing is mathematician Andrew Simoson, he also looked at the fall time for a piecewise description of Earth’s internal field, and has written some cool stuff factoring in the rotation.
    I must warn you about the arxiv version, the section on brachistochrones has a theoretical error so those results based on the internal profile (particularly the mustache-looking paths) shouldn’t be trusted. It was corrected in the published version.


    • dougaj4 says:

      Hello Alex, I’m glad you found this post, and thanks for the warning on the brachistochrones. I’ll have a look at that when I have some time.

      I also had a look at the path for a hole across the equator, including the effect of rotation. I’ll add a link to that.

      Another related post was looking at Euler’s formula for buckling of columns, so I’ll add a link for that one.

      I’ll go and look up Andrew Simoson now.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s