The Dome of the Pantheon

I have recently made my first Wikipedia edit.

The article on the Pantheon in Rome made the following claim:

“The exact composition of the Roman concrete used in the dome remains a mystery. An unreinforced dome in these proportions made of modern concrete would hardly stand the load of its own weight, since concrete has very low tensile strength, yet the Pantheon has stood for centuries. It is known from Roman sources that their concrete is made up of a pasty Calcium hydroxide|hydrate of lime, with pozzolanic ash (Latin ”pulvis puteolanum”) and lightweight pumice from a nearby volcano, and fist-sized pieces of rock. In this, it is very similar to modern concrete. The high tensile strength appears to come from the way the concrete was applied in very small amounts and then was tamped down after every application to remove excess water and trapped air bubbles. This appears to have increased its strength enormously.”

Some quick research on the Internet found no evidence for the Roman concrete having particularly high strength, and this article: The Pantheon by David Moore quoted research showing that the maximum flexural tensile stresses were very low.

My edit was as follows:

It is known from Roman sources that their concrete is made up of a pasty hydrate of lime, with pozzolanic ash (Latin pulvis puteolanum) and lightweight pumice from a nearby volcano, and fist-sized pieces of rock. In this, it is very similar to modern concrete.[3] No tensile test results are available on the concrete used in the Pantheon; however Cowan discussed tests on ancient concrete from Roman ruins in Libya which gave a compressive strength of 2.8 ksi (20 MPa). An empirical relationship gives a tensile strength of 213 psi (1.5 MPa) for this specimen.[4] Finite element analysis of the structure by Mark and Hutchison[5] found a maximum tensile stress of only 18.5 psi (0.13 MPa) at the point where the dome joins the raised outer wall.[6] The stresses in the dome were found to be substantially reduced by the use of successively less dense concrete in higher layers of the dome. Mark and Hutchison estimated that if normal weight concrete had been used throughout the stresses in the arch would have been some 80% higher.

4. H. W. Cowan, The Master Builders. John Wiley and Son, New York, 1977, p. 56
5. R. Mark and P. Hutchinson, “On the Structure of the Pantheon”, Art Bulletin. March 1986
6. Moore, David, “The Pantheon”,, 1999

This entry was posted in Concrete, Newton and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to The Dome of the Pantheon

  1. Mike says:

    Great article. I will use this as a trivia question for my students.


  2. dougaj4 says:

    Mike – sounds like you have difficult trivia quizzes🙂


  3. Leah Luptak says:

    Reading Pompeii, even at 50, learning new things every day. It is so interesting, I’m going to do more research to help my understanding. I never just read a book, I have to understand……..thanks Mike


  4. Comando says:

    Have I read somewhere that the underground water supplies for Rome were lined with the same substance, and that on contact with water became impervious?


  5. dougaj4 says:

    Commando – Yes, their concrete was widely used in the aqueducts. Try Pompeii by Robert Harris for an entertaining read with some historically accurate information about the techniques used in the Roman water supply systems.


    • Comando says:

      In that case is it possible to utilize the Iceland Volcanic ash and make puteolanum. Seems that all this free ash going to waste could be used to make houses in devestated areas of the world.


      • KAROO says:

        Comando – yes, imagine what could be done with recycled volcanic ash, and other ancient and new materials that are going to waste just because people are so short-sighted and uninventive. In modern life we are spoilt for choice – too spoilt.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s